Fight scenes cover a wide range: a battle, a duel, a bar brawl, a struggle over a phone, a sibling shove that goes too far. The techniques are the same at every scale, and the most important one comes before anyone throws a punch.
Stakes before choreography
Ask three questions before you write a single blow. What does each side want? Not "to win" — to escape, to get the key, to make the other person admit something, to protect someone in the doorway. What happens if they lose? Death is the obvious answer and often the least interesting. Losing face in front of a younger brother can carry more weight. What will be different afterwards? If nothing changes, the fight is padding.
A fight is a scene like any other, and the rules from planning a chapter on one page apply: a goal, an obstacle, a turn, an outcome that moves the story.
Keep the geography simple
Readers get lost in fights mostly because they lose track of where people are. Establish the space before the violence starts, while the reader still has attention to spare: the narrow stairs, the table between them, the open window. Then use only a few landmarks during the fight, and refer back to them. "She was against the window now" does more work than three sentences of footwork.
Limit the number of moving parts. Two people are easy. Four are hard. In a large fight, stay with one viewpoint character and let the rest of the battle blur at the edges — which is also how it feels to be in one.
Write in beats, not moves
Break the fight into a few beats, each one a shift in who has the advantage. A beat might be several actions long, but it should end with the situation changed: she has the knife now, he is on the floor, the door is blocked. Summarise the actions inside a beat; slow down only at the turns.
At the sentence level, short sentences speed things up and long ones slow them down. Use both. A run of short sentences for the chaos, then one long sentence at the moment that matters, when time seems to stretch.
Use the body and the senses
Choreography is visual. Prose is better at everything else. The sound of a head hitting a cupboard. The taste of blood from a bitten tongue. How heavy the arms get after thirty seconds. Hands that will not stop shaking afterwards. One precise physical detail is worth a paragraph of manoeuvres.
Real fights are short, clumsy and exhausting. Untrained people miss, slip and grab clothes. Even trained characters get tired. Let the fight cost something physically, and let it keep costing in the next chapter: the bruise, the limp, the cut that reopens.
Keep characters thinking
The viewpoint character's thoughts are what make a fight readable and personal. Not an internal essay — fragments. "Not the face. Mum will see." A fight is also a moment of character: what someone does when they are frightened and have no time to choose tells the reader more than any description. The person who apologises while hitting you is not the same person who goes quiet.
Dialogue during a fight should be rare and short. People do not deliver speeches with their breath knocked out of them. If two characters need to argue, let them argue before or after.
Length
Most fight scenes are too long. A useful check: if a page goes by without the advantage changing hands, cut. A single chapter-ending fight rarely needs more than a few hundred words of actual violence; the build-up and the aftermath usually deserve more space than the fight itself. This is a pacing decision as much as a style one — more in how to pace a novel.
Common problems
- Stage directions. "He threw a left hook, she ducked and countered with an uppercut." Accurate, lifeless. Replace half of it with one consequence.
- The invincible lead. If your character never takes a hit, the reader stops worrying about them.
- The same fight twice. If two fights in a book have the same shape, the second will feel shorter and weaker. Change the space, the stakes, or who is fighting.
- No aftermath. The scene after a fight, when adrenaline drains and someone starts crying in the car, is often the one readers remember.
- Violence without weight. If a character kills someone and is fine by the next page, readers notice, even in a fantasy.
Testing it
Read the fight aloud. Wherever you stumble, a reader will too. Then ask someone who has not read the outline to tell you, in two sentences, what happened and who won. If they cannot, the problem is almost always geography or too many moving parts, not the prose. Feedback of this specific kind is the most useful sort: see how to get honest feedback on your writing.
We make Arwy, where you can publish a book chapter by chapter and readers can comment on the exact line where they got confused — handy for fight scenes in particular. It is on Android and in the browser; there is no iOS app yet.
Got a fight in your next chapter? Readers will tell you where they lost track. Arwy is on Google Play.
Writing something yourself? Everything we know about publishing it — free guides, how rights work, and what you can actually earn — is collected on Arwy for writers.
← All posts