Writing

How to find and fix plot holes in your story

Arwy/November 14, 2026

Readers forgive a lot. They forgive coincidence in the setup, a slow middle, an ending they did not want. What breaks their trust is the moment a story contradicts itself or ignores an obvious solution — and once they spot one plot hole, they start looking for more.

A plot hole is a gap or contradiction in a story's logic: something that should not be possible given what we know, an obvious alternative nobody considers, or a thread that simply vanishes. It is different from a mystery the story will explain later. The test is whether the reader is meant to wonder about it.

Not every unexplained thing is a hole. It becomes one when the reader notices it and the story gives them no reason to keep trusting it.

The common kinds

  • "Why didn't they just…?" The character could have called someone, used the thing they already had, or walked away. The plot only works because they do not.
  • Broken rules. A magic system, technology or institution works one way in chapter three and another way when the plot needs it.
  • Impossible timing. A character travels too far too fast, or two events that must be days apart happen on the same evening.
  • Knowledge leaks. A character acts on information they never received.
  • Forgotten threads. A setup — a threat, a promise, a missing letter — that is never paid off. This is the reverse of Chekhov's gun.
  • Motivation gaps. A character does something important with no reason the reader can see, only because the plot needs it.

Why they happen

Most plot holes come from revision rather than ignorance. You change a detail in chapter five and forget it was relied on in chapter twelve. You add a new character who could obviously solve an old problem. Serial fiction is especially exposed, because early chapters are already public when later ones are written and cannot always be changed quietly.

Finding them: four passes

1. Build a timeline. List every scene with its day and time, and where each major character is. Impossible journeys and overlapping events become obvious on a list in a way they never are in prose.

2. Track knowledge. For key secrets, note the chapter where each character learns them. Then check that no one acts on a secret before that chapter.

3. Cause and effect. Summarise the plot as a chain of "because" sentences: she goes to the station because the letter said so. Where you have to write "and then" instead of "because", look closely; the logic may be missing.

4. Ask the obvious question. At every major obstacle, ask what a sensible person would do. If the answer is easy and your character does not do it, you need a reason.

A series bible makes the first two passes much easier on long projects.

Fixing them

Close the exit. Give a reason the easy solution is not available: the phone is dead, the friend is the person they cannot trust, calling the police would expose their own crime. One line, placed before the reader asks, is often enough.

Have a character notice. Sometimes the best fix is to let someone ask the reader's question aloud and get an answer. This is called "hanging a lantern" on a problem: acknowledging it shows the reader you are aware and keeps their trust.

Move information earlier. If a character uses a skill or object at the climax, plant it earlier. The technique is the same as in foreshadowing.

Cut the element that creates the hole. Often the cleanest fix is removing a detail you added for colour that accidentally broke the logic.

Make it a mystery. If something unexplained could become intriguing rather than careless, make the characters notice it and leave it open on purpose — then make sure you answer it.

Holes in published serials

If readers spot a hole in a chapter that is already out, you have options. A small fix to the earlier chapter, with a short author's note, is usually fine; tell readers what changed if it matters to the plot. If you cannot change the past, solve it forward: a later scene reveals the reason. What does not work is ignoring it; readers who noticed will notice again. There is advice on talking to readers in how to write an author's note.

Not everything needs fixing

Readers accept a convenient coincidence that starts a story far more easily than one that solves it. They also ignore holes in matters the story does not care about. Spend your effort on holes near the climax and in the main line; a minor timing issue in a side scene matters much less.

We make Arwy, where writers publish chapter by chapter and readers can comment on a single line — and where readers point out "but why didn't she just call him?" before the book is finished. It is on Android and in the browser; there is no iOS app yet.


Readers are very good at finding holes. Let a few of them read before the ending. Arwy is on Google Play.

Writing something yourself? Everything we know about publishing it — free guides, how rights work, and what you can actually earn — is collected on Arwy for writers.

← All posts