A note on who wrote this: we make Arwy, so we have an obvious interest. We've tried to describe the others fairly and to be clear about where Arwy is the wrong choice — a comparison that concludes "use ours for everything" isn't worth reading.
What actually decides this
Three questions, in order. What are you writing? Serialised fiction, essays, fan work and standalone novels all have different natural homes. Do you want readers or subscribers? Those are different systems. Do you want feedback while you write, or after? Serial platforms give you the first; finished-book platforms give you the second, if at all.
Pick for the shape of what you're writing, not for the biggest number of users. A huge platform in the wrong genre is a quiet room.
Wattpad — the largest serial fiction audience
Good for: romance, YA, fanfiction-adjacent original work; writers who want the biggest possible pool of readers for serialised chapters.
Trade-off: that scale means enormous competition for attention, and discovery leans heavily toward what's already popular. Strong genre fit matters more here than anywhere else.
Royal Road — progression fantasy and LitRPG
Good for: web serials in fantasy, LitRPG and progression fiction. A focused, engaged readership that reads chapter by chapter and comments in detail.
Trade-off: if you're not writing in or near those genres, you're in the wrong building.
Archive of Our Own — fan work
Good for: fanfiction, with an exceptional tagging system and a non-commercial, reader-first culture.
Trade-off: it is not built for original fiction or for building a career, deliberately. No monetisation by design.
Medium — essays and non-fiction
Good for: standalone essays, opinion, tech and personal writing; built-in distribution to readers browsing topics.
Trade-off: a poor home for serialised fiction — the format and the audience both point elsewhere.
Substack — writing to a list
Good for: writers who want to own their audience directly, by email, with subscriptions.
Trade-off: discovery is largely your job. It rewards people who already have an audience or are willing to build one off-platform. A first-time fiction writer with no following will find it very quiet.
Arwy — serialised fiction with readers who talk back
Good for: publishing chapter by chapter to readers who are already there to read. Readers comment on the specific line rather than the whole book, you can see which chapter people stop at, and the app connects readers of the same book to each other — so your book acquires a small community rather than a view count. Free to publish, you keep all rights, and there's an optional earning layer (how that works).
Where it's the wrong choice: if you're writing essays or non-fiction, use Medium or Substack. If you're writing fanfiction, use AO3. If you have a finished novel and want it sold as a book, this isn't a store. And it's Android-only for now — no iOS.
The honest summary
Essays → Medium or Substack. Fan work → AO3. Progression fantasy → Royal Road. Big-audience romance and YA serials → Wattpad. Serialised fiction where you want close reader feedback and a community around the book → Arwy.
And whichever you choose, the platform is not the hard part. Getting the first ten readers is, and that's mostly craft and persistence — see how to get your first readers and how to write a first chapter people finish.
Publishing serialised fiction and want readers who talk back? Try Arwy.
Writing something yourself? Everything we know about publishing it — free guides, how rights work, and what you can actually earn — is collected on Arwy for writers.
← All posts